Saturday, 27 August 2005

Comic book review - Invincible: Family Matters

Invincible: Family MattersInvincible: Family Matters
Robert Kirkman: Co-creator, writer, letterer
Cory walker: Co-creator, artist
Bill Crabtree: Colourist

Kurt Busiek puts it well in the introduction when he says that he didn't give Invincible another look when it first came out as it didn't look like anything new. I agreed and didn't try it. Good reviews, and the insistence of Clandestine Chum Logan, finally wore me down and I got the first trade, collecting issues #1–4.

And, here was the strange thing: I kept coming back to it.

I read it, enjoyed it, put it down. Then I picked it up again and read it again, and enjoyed it again.

It's rare that I do this; I have a good memory, so find it hard to reread something as I already know the story beats, and only do it if the book is particularly information-dense or for a review. Invincible isn't text-heavy but I couldn't stop enjoying the damn book. What gives?

I think it's because Invincible is a pure slice of comic book delight.

The story is lean, no fat, but not decompressed. The art is sleek and cool. The characters are strong and defined. The themes are resonant. And the whole package is a sheer pleasure.

You know you are in for a treat when you start off with a masturbation joke; our hero, Mark, is spending too long on the toilet reading a comic, which gets his Mum worried about all the time spent in the bathroom. There's a smile on my face as we begin.

Mark Grayson is the son of Omni-man, a super-hero who is basically Superman, an alien from another planet, and his Mum, an Earth woman. They take it in their stride when Dad is out, by watching the TV news: 'Well, now you know where he is,' says Mark. Mum replies, 'I hope he brings back something nice for me. I've never been to Taiwan.' This demonstrates a playful sense of a comic book world without the intensity that seems prevalent in some books I could mention.

Mark discovers he is developing super-powers; his facial reaction alone is priceless, as is his response: 'It's about time.' This casualness is reflected in the family dynamic; Dad casually chatting about stopping dragons and averting an enchanted flood. When Mark reveals that he is getting superpowers, Mum simply says, 'That's nice. Can you pass the potatoes?'

When Mark decides to fight crime, Dad watches casually while leaning on a wall as his son tackles some bank robbers before introducing him to the tailor who made his costume. When asked what sort of suit he wants, Mark asks for iconic. The costumier replies, 'Everyone wants iconic costumes but no one knows what that means.' Kirkman is having fun with the genre, playing with tropes, but without ridiculing or parodying, and indicating his feel for the material, as well as his love.

I've talked about the writing aspects, but I shouldn't ignore what Cory Walker brings to the book. His artwork (Busiek gets it again: 'his clean, clear storytelling, his deadpan characterisation, his sleek designs, his distinctive, stylised rendering …') is able to handle everything – the super-heroic, the family, the talking heads, the variety of different faces and body shapes in school. He has a lovely touch and tells the story well, with precision and clarity. I even like the way he draws little curls in people's noses and in their knuckles. Bill Crabtree's colours are an unusual but entirely appropriate palate – somehow muted and bright at the same time, a variation on the traditional use of the primary colours to indicate a hint of reality with the undeniable fact that this is a comic book.

Mark discovers his super-hero name by having a talking-to from the principal after he sorts out a bully during school hours. For this, we should be grateful to Bulletproof Monk, which is something I thought I'd never see myself type. Originally, he was going to be called Bulletproof, which is a stupid name. Fortunately, Bulletproof Monk was just coming out at Image, so it was decided to change as it would confuse things. Hence, Invincible was born.

The second issue sees Dad telling Mark about his origin - how he came from the planet Viltrum (where all men seem to have the same large moustache as he does), a utopia that looks after the evolution of others. He volunteered to be sole protector of Earth when his planet decided not look after it, even though it meant he might never return. He reveals that it is highly likely that Mark will inherit these powers. It is only then that we are shown that it is quite a young Mark who is being told this story; his response is stunned silence, followed by, 'Wow. I'm going to be able to fly?' You've got no choice but to adore this book.

This cuts to Mark flying at night, simply revelling in the wonder of flight. He notices a crime in progress and, in dealing with it, he comes into contact with Teen Team, a group of teenage super-heroes, consisting of Robot, Atom Eve, Rex Splode and Dupli-Kate. (There is a nice visual of one of Dupli-Kate's duplicates waving during the introductions.) Mark thinks he recognises Atom Eve, and vice versa, a feeling that is confirmed when they realise they are in the same physics class, which adds a great dynamic into the story, as well as humour; when Mark yawns after the late night, Sam (Atom Eve) replies: 'Teen super-heroes start drinking coffee at an early age.'

Mark & Sam change around the back of a dumpster and fly to the Teen Team HQ, where Robot has set plans to find the leader of the criminal that Mark stopped last night. They tag along and apprehend him, leading to an invitation to join the team. If only all life were this simple … To counterpoint this, the book ends with a teenage boy waking in a mall, confused and discovering he has a bomb for a torso – which explodes.

The next issue is a full issue. We learn that there are three kids missing from the school Mark attends (Reginald Vel Johnson School – Reginald is perhaps best well known as Sgt. Al Powell in the Die Hard films; someone must be a fan …). We learn that Mark's Dad is a semi-famous novelist. Mark quits Burger Mart (His only worry? 'My Dad's going to kill me.') but Dad tells him he doesn't need to work there anyway, what with being a super-hero, and goes on patrol with him: 'I think we're about due for a team-up.' 'Eh. You said "team-up."' There then follows a lovely couple of pages of father and son flying side by side in essentially the same panel down the page, with the occasional 'whoooosh' as Dad zips off to save someone. It's a joyous and touching scene, with real emotional resonance.

While having lunch, Dad has to fly off for an emergency, but he returns to ask for Mark's help. The three panels express it the feeling succinctly, from the look on Mark's face to the empty panel with a half-eaten hot-dog suspended in mid air. There is an alien invasion, an endless stream of soldiers through a portal but time here affects them differently and they start to age rapidly, causing them to withdraw. But not after Dad explodes with anger at the aliens: 'Get off my planet!' Is this something Mark should be worried about?

There is mention of Guardians of the Globe and Megaforce, hinting at a world of super-heroes and a world full of the fantasy of comic book universes. These nice little touches make the book seem even more real, even though this is the third book in the series.

Another living bomb in a mall is seen by Omni-man, who throws him into the sky before he explodes. Mark recognises him as one of the missing students, just before one of the aliens appears out of nowhere and disappears with Omni-man. When Mark goes home to tell Mum that Dad is missing, her reaction ('… Well, that's more pork chops for us') is dark humour hiding the deep worry and love she feels, that helps to make her character feel more real.

The concept – what would it be like to be Superman's family, basically – is not treated lightly but with thought about the relationships and interactions that might occur in a more-complex realisation of the Silver Age concept, and is one of the focal points of the book that make it different and ring emotionally true.

Another is the dialogue that exists between characters, which plays with familiar ideas in comic books but in a knowing and sly manner: 'Curses … foiled again' and 'Off to the cafeteria dumpster' are very funny used here.

The fourth issue sees the revealing of the bomber, the return of Omni-man (the tear of thanks by Mum at his return hits more emotional wallop than a big scene), and finishes with the normality of the family dinner: when Mum asks, 'Anything interesting happen to either of you today' and Mark and Dad give a précis of their time, she replies, 'That's nice. Who's ready for dessert?'

This is a book about a super-hero and family but it has humour, a lightness of touch and a hint of reality that makes it well worth your while seeking it out. Don't be like me and wait too long to get in on something really good.

Grade: A

(Hope that keeps you busy for a while. See you in a week – holiday, here I come...)

Friday, 26 August 2005

Pondering your opinions...

I didn’t post yesterday because I was thinking about what I did in asking for people’s opinions and thinking about the comments that were left in response. I’d like to thank everyone who took the time to leave a comment; I really appreciate it and read what you said with interest.

The evening after publishing the post, I started to regret it and even contemplated removing it. It looked like I was being needy and looking for an ego massage and perhaps even a bit pathetic. This wasn’t the intent – I am genuinely interested in what other people reading my stuff think. So, apologies if the message came across a bit crass.

To respond to some of the points: Logan, I had the same feeling about Blogger’s comments system, and tried inputting Haloscan, but my web-fu was weak and I wasn’t happy with the way it looked. I’ve seen that Blogger have changed to try and emulate Haloscan with the comments appearing as a separate pop-up (and I like the fact that you can get people’s blog picture in there, as it’s a nice functionality), but it doesn’t seem to be working on my site yet. I’ve asked Blogger Helpdesk and wait to see what happens; if nothing comes of it, I’ll give Haloscan another go.

Regarding the issue of comics outside of my normal selection, it’s something I’d like to do, but it mainly comes down to money and taste. Money because it’s hard to justify buying something I don’t actively want (I’m not a rich man). Taste because … well, I don’t know if I’m a genre fan (as Paul O’Brien said in his infamous post) or if I don’t have a taste for what might be considered the ‘artier’ aspect of comics, such as Blankets or James Kochalka’s work but, then again, I don’t have much of a taste for the excessively arty in other media, such as cinema or books. I appreciate the offer, though. I do intend to try something different and outside of my normal range, as a way of stretching my reviewing abilities, so we shall see.

Jason, I understand what you are getting at; there is a lot of the formula to my blog and others, so it’s a fully justifiable criticism. Part of this is due to my laziness – the links, solicitations, picks and reviews are easy to do, whereas the individuality of which you speak requires effort. This is something I have a problem with but is something I intend to try and rectify. I have quite a few ideas for, for want of a better word, pieces that I want to try which will involve doing research and writing which will hopefully broaden the range and develop some individuality to the site.

Greg, same as Logan and Jason :)

Mark, I get what you’re saying, although I don’t think I’m looking for notice and recognition (unless it’s a subconscious thing, and I am an attention-seeking whore without realising it). I think I’m trying to accomplish several things with this site, but haven’t succeeded yet :) But what you said has given me food for thought, so thanks.

James, I hope I’m not completely lacking in fun, but I get what you mean. Your '10 Greatest Comic Battles Ever' is an example of the sort of thing I want to do, once I get off my lazy arse and put in the effort. My stuff won’t be as good as yours, obviously, but it has got my brain working in ways it hadn’t regarding this blog, joining bizarre connections and creating new ones, which will hopefully be reflected in the future. I don’t know about letting my hair down – I’ve always had it cut pretty short :)

I used to think that I could write regular posts based on some sort of inspiration creating a frenzy of creativity. This was quite retarded thinking and so I hope to start writing more focussed pieces, which might mean not posting everyday, which I have to realise isn’t the most important thing in the world.

Well, that was an incredibly self-indulgent post, wasn’t it? Bloggers thinking out loud in their blogs – it’s blogsterbation, for goodness sake. To make up for this, I will post a long review of a book I should have got ages ago (once Blogger is working normally again, that is, and allows me to upload images).

Wednesday, 24 August 2005

Now, I want YOUR opinions...

Having accepted the Blogaround challenge (in this post) and then reading that Evan very kindly said nice things about me in this post, after I emailed & blogged some constructive criticism of his site after he asked for opinion of his site, and saw that he got some good criticism from other kindly comic bloggers, it got me thinking – would it be brazen of me to ask for your opinion of this blog? I primarily post for myself but I also want other people to read my blog, so it would be helpful and interesting to know what people think of the blog and what they would want to read here as well.

So, I WANT YOU AND YOUR OPINIONS – I want your non-clandestine criticisms …

Please feel free to either email or leave a comment with your thoughts, criticisms and suggestions regarding this blog; all will be gratefully accepted. Thank you in advance.

And now, I’m going to tell you what comics I will be buying this week for my own nefarious reasons:
Jack Cross #1
Jack Cross #1
Legion of Super-Heroes #9
Daredevil #76
Queen & Country: Declassified v2 #2

Note that I am not getting Q&C: Declassified v3 because it is not by Mr. Rucka, no offence to Mr. Johnston. This is probably very silly but I’m not a fan of spin-off material done by someone other than the original creator. I don’t know if it’s because I’ve been burned by bad experiences (which I have erased from my memory, as I can’t recall any specific examples) or if it’s a rule of thumb supposedly skewing towards a principle. I feel bad because it is Oni but don’t want to go back on my guideline.

I’m looking forward to Jack Cross, as I’m partial to Ellis, spies and violent gun-play, which is covered by this single book – how lucky am I? Daredevil #76 begins Bendis & Maleev’s final arc, so I’m expecting big things; Bendis has been telling some very good stories, so his final tale should be a doozy.

In other stuff, Greg lets you know that you should own Avengers Forever, and he is quite correct. Logan answers my question regarding why he has so many crap DVDs in his collection. And Peter David talks about the new X-Factor book, which is fortunately not called New X-Factor.

Tuesday, 23 August 2005

Blogaround challenge

(Am I the only one to think of the television programme Runaround when I say the word 'blogaround' in my head, or is that too British-specific a reference?)

As suggested by Laura, according to her rules, I take … The Blogaround Challenge:

Love Manga
This is a nicely designed site with lots of info on manga, which is why I don’t usually read it. I’m scared to dip my toes into the waters of manga because it is so huge. But David makes it accessible and his enthusiasm for the form shines through.

Superblog!!
This is a wonderfully deranged site, with lots of bizarre things posted on a regular basis. I read 9 posts and none of them were about comics, so I should check out more to see if it’s a regular part of the site. Still, any site that has talks about about their love for Carla Gugino can’t be bad …

Successless Comic Blog
This is an offshoot for boyfriend and girlfriend Dylan and Serene where they do all their posting about comics. It’s quite new, but they been doing their other sites for a while, so they have a nice, relaxed writing style. Dylan seems to be undertaking the ambitious task of writing about the Cerebus phone books, for which he deserves credit and probably hospitalisation; hope it doesn’t turn him into Dave Sim …

Irresponsible Pictures
This is another manga blog, which is probably why I haven’t really read it before. It appears to be mostly linking to manga-related post and information, which is a good way for me to find out more about manga, but there is also some comment from Pata as well, in a enjoyable tone.

Bloggity-Blog-Blog-Blog
The challenger herself – Laura has been doing this a while now, as you can tell from her site, which is very up-to-date and well-laid out, but I never got in the habit of reading her regularly perhaps, I think, because of the inclusion of journal-type posts (which I only find interesting if I know the person or if the subject is something I know about – I know, I’m so snobbish …). However, the blog is a mix of linkarounds, which are very craftily written so that you want to click on the link and find out more from her entertaining comments, the journal-type, and her ‘Rapid Reviews’ with the (I assume) starfish to grade the comics (due to her love of Aquaman). In fact, reading her blog again means I’ll have to read it more often.

The Four Colour Media Monitor
This does what it says on the tin; it provides links to other (professional and amateur) sites talking about comics of the moment. Avi provides some comment as well; if the archives are to be believed, it’s only been around for two months, but it doesn’t feel like that, which is a good sign in my books (even if Avi doesn’t seem to like Grant Morrison, which is practically heresy).

Trash Heap
JK seems to be another long time blogger; I don’t think I’ve ever read this before, but I will be checking it out from now on. From comics to pop culture stuff, there is a lot of crossover in my tastes, and an entertaining attitude to it all as well. And I agree with JK on the annoyance of Blogger’s image interface – why DOES it put any image, after the first one, at the top of the post?

The Comic Asylum
James’s site is perhaps one of the best reasons for the blogaround challenge; discovering a site you hadn’t tried before that you enjoy and admire. He has interesting thoughts on aspects of comics (from looking at why Annuals should be something of substance, to his detailed and researched look at his greatest comics battles) with a nice writing style. It’s so good that it makes me green with envy and have to find something to nitpick! So, James, you should either not add your name to your posts, or remove it from your permanent link signature, as it just makes you sound so proud of your name :)

Cognitive Dissonance
Johanna is a pillar of the online comic reviewing community, her Comics Worth Reading site being a mainstay and always an interesting read. Similarly, her blog is a good read, with its variety of commentary, linking and reviews. Although our tastes don’t cross over all the time, I will listen to her recommendations because she has clear opinions which are expressed eloquently, which is a skill I admire.

Chipped Ham Productions
Evan has been blogging for a while now, although, in his latest post, he asks for people’s thoughts on his blog, as he feels he doesn’t get enough visitors. His site is well presented and he posts some of the ‘classical’ comic blog topics, such as looking at the solicitations from the big publishers and suggestions for comics on new comic day. The thing missing for me is how he feels about the books on a personal level – there is a hint, but not enough, of how much or little he gets from the books he reads. The closest he gets is in talking about the trade for the original Excalibur in this post; I’d like to see more of that in his blog. I haven’t done a full search of his site, but he doesn’t seem to review the books he reads, which would give an indication of his personality more on the blog. This is, of course, in my humble opinion, and I can hardly be considered an expert, what with hardly any comments or staggering visitor numbers myself. But, he did ask for people's opinions :)

And that’s ten. Well, that was an interesting experiment. Thanks, Laura. I might have to do this again in a month or so; I’ll also have to do that post about the blogs that I read regularly as well. And to all I have commented upon, keep up the good work.

Monday, 22 August 2005

Low calorie posting

I'm not feeling too hot today, so no content-rich post from the Clandestine Critic today (see how unwell I am – I referred to myself in the third person …)

Instead, a little stroll through around the inter-porn-web-net, as I comment on a few things I've seen …

Paul O'Brien, after the madness of the comments caused by his Ninth Art article, has a State of the X-Axis in which he announces the start of a new blog, If Destroyed, Still True, in which he writes reviews of non-comics things, such as films and comedy shows from the Edinburgh Festival. He is a very enjoyable writer to read, so it's great to see him spread his wings.

(According to Kung-Fu Jesus on Urban Dicitionary, If Destroyed, Still True is 'Added to the end of written insults (most likely graffiti) to say that even if it is removed, then the fact remains that the insult is true.' which, according to The Law of the Playground, is a primary school thing; I had never heard of it before, so it must be a Northern thing …)

Erik Larsen seems like a really good bloke based on his column. I particularly like his comment about having a letter printed in a comic: 'And there are few things more exciting than seeing your letter in print.' It's a topic I've been planning to post about, as I tell you all which comics I had letters published in and how I felt about them.

Greg has an interesting post about comics that have good books that have ‘failed’ by not getting past the 10-issue mark, based on the demise of The Intimates. In the comments, people rightly mention Vext, Heckler and Chase as other examples. I think that Greg’s cut-off point is a little low, mainly because it means that Xero doesn’t count because it only got to 12 issues, but it could be a time thing; back then, 12 issues was a failure; nowadays, not getting to the year is perhaps more common.

Logan confuses me by purchasing National Treasure, a film he has never seen and then being surprised when he doesn’t enjoy it. I find this baffling, personally, especially as he could have read my review :) As I state in his comments, I have a DVD purchase policy: I only buy DVDs that I really enjoyed, either seeing them in the cinema or on DVD beforehand, and then they should have good extras. If they are vanilla discs, then they get purchased when cheap (e.g. when Virgin or HMV does a sale and they go down to <£6).

Reading this post from Mark, I found out about the blogaround challenge set by Laura, which sounds like an excellent idea, and is something I intend to do when at full strength. It’s something I’d been considering doing recently, talking about the various blogs I read and why I enjoy them, so a case of convergent evolution, I think. And I’m not doing it because Jim says nice things about me in his post in response to the challenge …

Hopefully, I'll be up to more posting tomorrow.

Saturday, 20 August 2005

I need to buy more comics to review...

So, this is what Saturday morning looks like …

Only two comics purchased this week, so let's take a quick look at them.

Authority: Revolution #11
In which Bendix reveals how he has controlled things from the beginning, with the aid of The Evolutionaries to set up Midnighter, and warp him with nanites. It's easy to say now that the alternate future vision didn't seem enough to convince Midnighter, which is how I felt, and Brubaker seems to understand that, suggesting that Midnighter was easy to convince of this. But this hasn't been the most original plotting from Brubaker, just picking up on what has gone before, with the inclusion or mentions of Rose Tattoo and Krigstein from previous incarnations. In fact, Brubaker seems to be trying to channel Ellis and Millar, with his attempts at the dialogue: 'I'm going to skullfuck you while you're still alive, you piece of shit …'; 'That's right, cock-head …'

Nguyen's art doesn't seem as natural as his run on Wildcats. Any artist should evolve, as is their right, but the linework seems a little harsher, the anatomy more blocky and enigmatic, and the panels not as fluid. It should be the big fight scenes at the end that it should open up and show off his obvious talent but it seems more restrained and harsher. The combination of Nguyen and Brubaker on Authority should have worked some magic but this is quite a traditional super-hero story, just with swear words. There are nice touches and it's nice to see Jenny Quantum like her old self but the story as a whole hasn't really spread its wings and soared.

Seven Soldiers: Klarion #3
In which Klarion discovers that Melmoth is a villain who is going to destroy Limbo. This seems a detour for the story, with Morrison having some fun with teenage dialogue and throwing in references for long-time DC fans (I don't have huge knowledge, but even I recall that it was a Dr Erdel that brought J'onn J'onnz to Earth, making it a nice touch in the Erdel Gate, and there are easter eggs in the museum). Irvings's art seems more comfortable drawing Klarion and Melmoth but not quite so at home drawing the teenagers, who look a tad bizarre, making for a not completely satisfactory package. However, it is a minor blip in a huge tapestry of storytelling and it will still be interesting to read the whole maxi-series in one sitting.

Friday, 19 August 2005

Film Review: The Island

The Island © Dreamworks It might not be cool to espouse the opinion that Michael Bay can make a visually slick film but, there, I’ve said it. Yes, he has a fondness bordering on the fetish for explosions and car chases, and his films can never be regarded as complex. However, if you want a slick popcorn flick, he’s the man to go to for the explodo. Bad Boys was a loud slice of buddy-comedy-action, The Rock is one of the best popcorn films around and Armageddon, albeit very silly, is enjoyable nonsense that looks good. I won’t defend Pearl Harbor – I’m not that stupid – but the bomb POV shot was cool, even if it seems quite sick in retrospect to watch the harbinger of death in such glorifying visuals.

All of which brings us to The Island, Bay’s latest assault on the visual and aural senses. He is the appropriate choice for this type of movie; he was asked by Steven Spielberg to direct it, so it’s not like I’m the only one who agrees. And he directs this well, shooting pretty pictures and pretty people (he particularly likes having women with long legs in short skirts in there for no other reason than he obviously likes it; not that I’m going to complain about it …) and moves it all along at a quick pace, which is how these things should be done.

The film sees Lincoln Six Echo (McGregor) in a containment facility for people who have survived a disaster in the near future and who must remain there while they recover and wait for the Lottery to pick them to go to The Island, the only untouched place on the planet. (Did they clone gullibility into people as well? Who is going to believe that a disaster wouldn’t affect the whole planet? As an aside, I feel the film was slightly spoiled by the pre-knowledge of them being clones, not in a 'Oh, no, it’s completely ruined my enjoyment' way, but in the care in which they take in the film to maintain the illusion prior to the chase scenes.) Lincoln feels there should be something more to life in the facility and his curiosity leads him to discover the truth; that the Island isn’t real and that they are going to die. Taking Jordan Two Delta (Johansson) with him when he flees, they escape the facility, while being chased by crack mercenary (Hounsou). When they get out, they are helped by a worker and friend (Buscemi) who tells them the truth that they are clones and they seek out their originals to reveal the truth.

This is fun but silly stuff that doesn’t bear up to excessive scrutiny – couldn’t the clones have been kept in a hospital environment where they are not allowed to move, so that they couldn’t escape? – but gives you an enjoyable enough ride. The central idea is very nice but not used for any deeper subtext. The actors don’t have to do much apart from look good at the right time, especially poor Scarlett, who pouts and runs on queue. Ewan comes across better as the main focus, and there are some lovely scenes with him and his sponsor (played by Ewan but with his natural Scottish accent, which allows him to call himself 'wanker' and say 'shite', something you can never have enough of in blockbuster films), that are very funny and interesting. Buscemi also comes out well, playing a small part with his humour, although not as outrĂ© as he was in Bay’s Armageddon. Strangely, it is these smaller scenes between the action that Bay shows a very delicate touch, allowing the dialogue and humour to come through, which is very refreshing.

The action scenes, which are the whole point of this film really, are up to scratch, as Bay eschews CGI (except to portray the future) in favour of hands-on stunts. This adds a realism that makes the action more exciting; compare the metal-crunching chase when the cars are crushed by what look like old train wheels falling off the back of an juggernaut, with the CGI-enhanced freeway scene of the Matrix Reloaded. They can sometimes be a little too relentless and Bay likes to whip his camera around too much to make it look like things are happening faster than they are, but you know you are in the hands of someone who isn’t afraid of a little spectacle.

I’m not saying this film is great, being a mish-mash of other films (don’t mention Logan’s Run, for example), but it is a fun slice of visual entertainment that you’ll enjoy for the duration and not much more. Not a ringing endorsement, perhaps, but not a slamming put down either. Disengage brain and have some explodo fun.

Rating: VID

Thursday, 18 August 2005

Marvel's November solicitations

Let us take a gander at Marvel's November solicitations:

Marvel confuses me: apparently Microman and Mantor the Magician are 'Marvel Milestones' whereas Spider-Man & The Black Cat #1–3 are 'Marvel Must Haves'. Are they for real, or do they just like alliteration? Reading on Kevin Smith’s blog about how he continually blew off Joe Quesada, a man he calls a friend, for the script was rather depressing and doesn’t fill me with enthusiasm concerning how it ends.

Black Panther #14What Marvel is good at is having nice covers for comics I’m not buying, such as the groove-a-delic Black Panther cover by Gary Frank, or the Ultimate X-Men cover, apparently by Stuart Immonen, or the latest Drax the Destroyer by Mitch Breitweiser. Of course, there are some that don’t work so well, such as Ultimate Fantastic Four, which seems to be a still from a bizarre pop duet video, or Daredevil: Father, which makes it look like Matt Murdock is having a painful rectal prolapse (are there any other kind?).

Of note for this month, Ed Brubaker writes a Doom mini-series; I haven’t read his Captain America because I just don’t 'get' the character but it looks like he might have a home at Marvel. Also, there is the Fantastic Four: The Wedding Special by Karl Kesel and Drew Johnson – you’ve got to feel sorry for Drew, when his interior work has to match up to the Gene Ha cover. A curiosity comes in the form of Marvel Team-Up #14, in which Kirkman’s creator-owned Invincible jumps into the Marvel universe. Having recently discovered the joys of Invincible, I’m tempted, especially with Cory Walker on art duties.

The big push goes to Captain Universe, a Marvel concept from before my time, with a slightly goofy costume and concept – the Uni-Power? Oh dear. Still, at least the Daniel Acuna covers are quite striking; is he doing any interior work yet?

Dan Slott, having worked his magic on She-Hulk, seems a perfect fit for writing a new ongoing Thing series, although I’ve never understood why he got his own series in the first place. Surely the whole point of the Fantastic Four was that they are a family, which sort of implies a joint unit. Not that I’m cynical or anything but we’ll see how long this lasts …

New Excalibur #1NEW Excalibur? Are Marvel just trying to keep Claremont happy or something? I can’t see the point otherwise, and the team seems to be a strange mix – why have Juggernaut and Dazzler based in the UK? Are they Anglophiles? And, being a Londoner, I find the cover quite insulting, as the group poses on Westminster Bridge in front of the Clock Tower containing Big Ben and the Houses of Parliament. I hate the generic shots of these landmarks as a shortcut for London and can’t understand why they would be standing in the middle of a bridge for no reason. Is there a super-villain tourist taking too many pictures? Or is there a super-villain black marketeer selling pirate DVDs? (Which you are more likely to come across on Westminster Bridge these days …)

X-Factor #1For better news in the X-world this month, X-Factor is back! With Guido! By Peter David! And Ryan Sook on artwork! I’m looking forward to this, as PAD's short tenure on the book back in the mists of time was a highlight of the series. Also, Brubaker (gosh, he’s a busy man) brings us X-Men: Deadly Genesis with Trevor Hairsine, which looks like it might be interesting, if the strangely-worded description of 'mysterious blend of horror and super-heroics' is to be believed.

That’s the last of the comic blogger’s obligatory solicitations posts for another month, which means I’ll have to think of something new to blog about next …

Wednesday, 17 August 2005

Monsieur Ambassador, you are spoiling us ...

A lot to get through today; Image solicitations, my comics for the week, some reviews and bits. It’s like buses …

Image solicitations for November

Award for most hilarious line of blurb goes to the Image Comics HC: 'ALL PREVIOUS ORDERS HAVE DECOMPOSED'. This is part of the Image problem, it has to be said; going through the list, other titles that have the line 'All previous orders cancelled' due to rescheduling are Ascend Special Edition HC, A Distant Soil, Vol. 4: Coda TP, The Athiest #3, Deadworld #3, Expatriate #4, Gødland #5 and Hawaiian Dick: The Last Resort #3. How are good titles going to get their audience if the audience can’t get their hands on them?

That said, the trade programme is going strong. Candidates include Girls vol. 1, Walking Dead vol. 4, Kabuki vol 5, Battle Pope and The Gift vol.2. And I will be getting all future Invincible trades, as I finally succumbed to pressure from Clandestine Chum Logan and got the first book and have to admit it is good stuff indeed.

Body Bags: The Hard WayJason Pearson will be writing and drawing new Body Bags, something that makes me happy, in a new one-shot, The Hard Way, which also includes colour reprints of Dark Horse material, to account for the rather hefty $5.99 price tag. Gulp.

Image does the Vertigo sampler with Image First TP, collecting Walking Dead, Girls, Sea of Red and Strange Girl #1s. I’ve heard good things about all of these, so it might be the best way to sample them all.

NYC Mech: Beta Love mini-series comes to a conclusion with a batch of quotes that should either be used for the start of the series or the ensuing collection. Rather odd, that.

Witchblade #92 is apparently the 10th Anniversary Special. I don’t know which is scarier; that Witchblade has made 10 years, or the bad mathematics …

Down #1Warren Ellis’s Down starts this month. Ellis hasn’t been pimping this in Bad Signal, which suggests a strange ambivalency towards this work, but I can’t resist his crime noir stylings with some Tony Harris and Cully Hamner art (see here for info).

Was anyone crying out for Top Cow/Marvel: The Crossover Collection? To my shame, I already own the Ellis written book (Ballistic or something) but surely this is filling the cheap bins of shops and dealers across the land?


Comics being rewarded by my hoarding of them this week:

Authority: Revolution #11
Seven Soldiers: Klarion the Witch Boy #3

… and that’s it. The sound you can hear is my wallet’s sigh of relief. I’ll be waiting for the trade on Defenders, the second issue of which is out this week but, otherwise, a light week which gives me the opportunity to catch up on some trades and re-reading old books for blogging purposes and deciding to keep them.


Quick Reviews

100 Bullets #63
I’m missing out on some of the nuances as I read from issue to issue but I still enjoy my burst of 100 Bullets, with the dialogue, art and plotting providing the monthly buzz. I found myself wondering if someone would have a samurai sword capable of decapitating someone; wouldn’t new reproductions not be sharp enough or are we supposed to believe that he had an old one and kept it in excellent condition? Nevertheless, it was a spectacular action finale to the Machiavellian plotting, making me want to know more.

Fables #40
In which the Adversary is revealed … or is he? Or how Gepetto came to rule the Fable world. Nice bit of storytelling, even if Buckingham hasn’t progressed as an artist past his impression/acquiring characteristics of early Chris Bachalo (when on Shade, The Changing Man). I would like to discuss the historical links but I am stupid; I don't even understand what Greg means when he calls him 'realpolitik politician' but it sums it up perfectly. That Greg sure is clever …

Seven Soldiers: Zatanna #3
Too. Much. Information. Brain. Overload. Hyper-dense storytelling from Grant Morrison and delicious artwork from Ryan Sook – do comics get any better than this?

Gravity #3
In which our hero gets some – wahoo! A wonderful coming-of-age story, told in the genre of super-heroes, in which Greg gets some priorities straight. A very enjoyable book all round.

Ultimate Annual #1
Kevin calls it best:
Steve Dillon does draw the living shit out of it
which elevates this slight tale to something more. There’s something about the weight that Dillon gives a character that makes them so much more real, which adds to any story he draws. It makes me want to pick up the Bullseye story he’s just finished with Daniel Way.

My reviews are quick but, for almost identical thoughts on nearly the same books but written with more pep and pizzazz, check out Johnny B in his latest Last Call column: he even digs John Paul Leon from his Challenger of the Unknown work, just like I do! (And I should know, I had a letter published in that book.)

Some other quick bits’n’pieces:

Paul O’Brien’s article, well written and thought out, on boredom with comic news and why he doesn’t read manga:
It's not that I have anything against manga. It's simply that, psychologically, I don't regard myself as a manga fan. I approach it as a wholly separate area that I'd be entering from scratch. And honestly, I don't have the time or inclination to do that. I've got a ton of books, CDs and DVDs to plough through already. Like a lot of more mainstream comics fans, I'm here primarily because I'm a genre fan rather than because of a devout love of the theoretical possibilities of the medium.

That isn't to say I'm not open to other types of comics, but it does mean I don't have the sort of "this is a comic, I must explore it" attitude that leads others to try and read their way into manga. I'm sure a lot of it is absolutely fantastic, but I could say that about my local bookstore too, and I've got a ton of books that are higher up my list of priorities because... well, I actually want to read them already.

Which turned into a huge discussion over on the Fanboy Rampage comments section when he llinked to it, with people wrongly accusing him of being bored with comics – it is one of the bizarrest things I’ve seen.

To lighten things up, you can see this post from Dave at his Long Box, which gave me a 'Nostalgasm'. And with that, I shall leave you.

Tuesday, 16 August 2005

DC Solicitations for November

I was supposed to be in Olso this past weekend for a friend’s wedding, but the problems with BA meant I didn’t go. This really bummed me out, which is why I haven’t posted the last couple of days. However, the posting of DC solicitations for November have cheered me up immensely and reminded me why I love comics so much. So, it’s that time again – comics from the future, today!

Nightwing #114I don’t read Nightwing and don’t really have an interest, but I do like the cover from Hester & Parks – a strong image, strikingly rendered.

Matt Wagner mines the history of Batman for his latest maxi-series, Batman and the Monster Men. From what I’ve read of his, he seems to get the Bat, but do we REALLY need this?

Gotham Central ties in with Infinite Crisis, which seems an intrusion, but hopefully it will mean an interesting character tale told from the human perspective, without having to read the rest of the crossover.


Infinite Crisis #2I like Jim Lee’s art, but this cover has me cringing with embarrassment. At least I won’t be buying it, but I feel sorry for people having to sell it in shops …

All the pre-Infinite Crisis books get the collected format this month – I’ll stick with the I Can’t Believe It’s Not The Justice League TP, thanks very much.

Grant Morrison finally gets his hands on Superman proper in All Star Superman, with the infamous cover by Quietly. I don’t think I can wait for the trade on this beauty …

Jack Cross #4This is a great cover design for Jack Cross #4 but does Erskine’s art look smoother and the characters prettier than normal? I’ve enjoyed his wonderfully craggy art from Knights of Pendragon and Firearm and City of Silence, where people looked real – has he had to make them ‘normal’ for the sake of a DCU book?

Grant Morrison continues to make me (and the majority of the comic blogging world) very happy with the start of two more of the Seven Soldiers mini-series: Bulleteer and Frankenstein, which both look spanking gorgeous.

Some great covers from the Wildstorm and Vertigo sections:
Desolation Jones #4100 Bullets #66
Fables #43Losers #30
Ex Machina #17Silent Dragon #5
ABC A-Z: Greyshirt and CobwebAnd, although my girlfriend will hate me for it, I do enjoy the cover for ABC A-Z: Greyshirt and Cobweb for the voluptuous rendition of Cobweb by the breast-fixated Terry Dodson. Yum …

The latest instalment of Losers in trade format for me to catch up on this great series, with yet another great cover.

Which brings me to the end of the solicitations, at least for me. Looks like a good month, if not for my wallet.

Thursday, 11 August 2005

Film review: Charlie and the Chocolate Factory

It’s a strange thing, nostalgia. It affects people differently. There are people, for example, who believe that Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory is a classic, Gene Wilder among them. They love the songs and Wilder’s performance and the ‘70s of it all. Personally, I put that down to seeing it as a child. I have the Oompa-Loompa song in my head still, and the image of Wilder getting his cane stuck in the paving and looking like he’s going to fall, only to roll out in the manner of a true showman, is imprinted in my psyche. However, it is not a great movie and is not a perfect adaptation of the book, even though the screenplay was written by Dahl himself.

All of which brings us to this version. Working from a script by John August that stays truer to the book (with a back-story element added and a different ending to avoid the glass elevator sequel), Tim Burton brings back his old pal, Johnny Depp, to play the part of disturbed man-child that is Willy Wonka. The story is mostly the same; Charlie Bucket is a poor boy who (eventually) gets one of the five Golden Tickets that will allow a child and a family member access to the amazing confectionary factory of the reclusive Willy Wonka.

Leaving aside the question of whether we actually needed an another adaptation, it can be said that this film looks quite lovely. Burton and his production designer have let their minds expand in order to bring to fruition the psychedelic interior of the chocolate factory. It was quite sumptuous to behold. But you could only notice that when you aren’t looking at Depp. He is hilarious as Wonka, with the teeth, costume, accent and attitude a joy to watch. While Wilder went for more sympathetic, Depp plays Wonka as disturbed and psychologically stunted, as he should be. When he first appears on the screen, seemingly out of nowhere, he brings laughter just by being there, so that you don’t mind the wonderful slapstick joke being repeated because it is so funny.

Everyone else plays second fiddle; Freddie Highmore as Charlie is good, although he doesn’t have much to do; Burton manages to get his other half, Helen Bonham Carter, into one of his films for the third time in a row; Christopher Lee looks like he’s walked in from another film but is good nonetheless, and it’s always good to see Noah Taylor in a big film again. All the other children and their parents are sufficiently odious but my favourite appearances were from Mark Heap and Kevin Eldon, as the dog walkers who reveal the Russian forgery, because they were in Spaced, the greatest sitcom ever.

The only strange choice was in narration – why was Geoffrey Holder narrating? (I had to look him up to find out that he was Baron Samedi in Live and Let Die.) His voice sounded slightly off, like a strange white man doing an impression of James Earl Jones. Or perhaps it was the sound at my cinema – it was very fuzzy, especially when trying to listen to the Oompa-Loompa songs, and definitely dampened the enjoyment of the film. That said, the songs were trying a bit too hard and, seeing as the first one was a complete musical (it was only watching it again recently on television that made me remember that there was a bloody song every five minutes) they should have perhaps played them down, but what can you do when you’ve got Danny Elfman doing the music?

On the whole, this film was an enjoyable experience without any of the quality to deserve re-watching, apart from the wonderful Depp. There are some nice touches (the use of 2001: A Space Odyssey was nice, and the filmic in-joke of having the television scene flit into the shower scene of Psycho where, famously, they used chocolate sauce to double for blood) and it’s interesting to see the comeuppances for the brats in CGI reality, even if it wasn’t necessary. It was in discussion with my girlfriend afterwards that she was able to pinpoint why; the first version, although different from the book and flawed in its own way, has an ending which leaves the audience with an emotionally satisfying feeling as they leave the film – Charlie shows he is worthy of the factory by being honest and returning the everlasting gobstopper. This film doesn’t have that, inserting an ending to do with Willy Wonka that brings the story full circle. It’s quite flat. Because the whole point of the book (and hopefully the film) is being unpleasant to horrible children for being greedy in their different ways, it seems strange to reward another greedy child (Wonka and his single-mindedness) with a happy ending.

Rating: VID

Wednesday, 10 August 2005

Contemplating CrossGen

I never read any CrossGen comics when they came out. I didn’t pay attention to the many press releases concerning their comics and was only dimly aware about the trouble they had and the bankruptcy. This was primarily due to a lack of interest on my part in their product, even if I applauded the intention behind it. It was another group of comics that I couldn't afford to try, so I ignored them.

Last weekend, while rummaging through a shop, I came across the Edge (the book, not the guitarist; although I do see famous people walking the streets of London all the bloody time), the cover you see to your left. This was an anthology collecting a selection of CrossGen comics, providing a flavour of their stories. They were priced at £2 each. Well, how could I resist around 200 pages of comics for the price of single comic today? So, I picked up Edge #1-8, collecting a few comics that I might have been interested in the first time round, such as Ruse and Way of the Rat. (For those of you in the London area who want to take advantage of the offer, it was Bookworld in the Wimbledon Shopping Centre.) It made me wonder about the CrossGen story, as I tried to explain to my girlfriend why I had bought a huge stack of books home. So I did some searching and here is some of what I found.

CrossGen CEO and publisher, Mark Alessi, launched the company in May 2000 with the intention of becoming the number one publisher of comic books. One year later, they were 5th largest; by 2003, they were number 4; in 2004, the company collapsed, painfully and loudly. They filed for bankruptcy, at over $3M in debt in Oct 2004, and Disney got their assets for $1M a short time later .

CrossGen were trying to break into new markets with different innovations, including an education programme, a comic on DVD, a regular and thorough trade paperback programme and a covering of genres outside of super-hero, including fantasy, sword & sourcery, sci-fi, space opera, detective fiction and wuxia. Personally, few of the titles sounded appealing to me, the majority of the talent producing it were not people whose work I would seek out, and the idea of a new universe (not new ideas, mind you; even though it was denied, there was the concept of a shared universe inherent in CrossGen books) made me balk at trying their product. Also, there was the sheer amount of titles they were pumping out. Instead of starting small and building on success, it seemed as if they were jumping in at the deep end, confident of success.

Reading about it now, I feel slightly guilty for picking up the books so cheap, as it looks like a lot of good people producing the work lost money and even their homes when they had to foreclose on missed mortgage payments, after Alessi relocated everyone down to Tampa, Florida, to work in the 'compound'. Part of the problem was book shops returning the trades, causing cash-flow problems, and the books I've purchased must have come from there. Should I feel guilty, or should I just enjoy the entertainment, as was the original intention? Even though the reviews will be out of date, I'll let you know what I think of them soon. What I do feel is sorry for the people who lost out and pity for the good idea that CrossGen was that didn't work out.

Some worthwhile links about the story of CrossGen:

A fascinating and in-depth analysis by Chris Fluit which I would urge you to read if you know as little as I did.

An overview of the revelation of financial problems by unpaid inkers at CrossGen at Newsarama.

This article sees Mark Alessi responding to these leaks, while this Permanent Damage sees Steven Grant sift through the response for the truth.

An informative conversation between Alan David Doane & Chris Allen.

The Comic Journal had an article about it all, which can be found here.

Finally, Augie gives a sympathetic overview in this article.

Isn’t it amazing what you can find on the internet? Kudos to CBR & Newsarama for their excellent search facilities, btw.

To digress completely, I wanted to point out this great post at Dial B for Blog about Radioactive Man covers. And it’s sad to see Clandestine Chum, Logan, is going on hiatus for a while. Hopefully, he’ll still be writing his Loose Staples column over at CBG. Come back soon, L.

Tuesday, 9 August 2005

Comics currently craved: A discussion of WHY


Comics I'm looking forward to reading the most this week:

100 Bullets #63
Fables #40
Seven Soldiers: Zatanna #3
Gravity #3
Ultimate Annual #1

I’m anticipating all these books, especially Zatanna, but it got me thinking about what I get on a monthly basis and trades I wait for later. Below is a list of the stuff I am buying and have been buying for the last 18 months or so, indicating whether it’s an ongoing series or a mini-series, the sort of book it is, and why I’m buying the monthly. This is a long one, so I hope you’re sitting comfortably …

100 Bullets (ongoing)
Crime conspiracy/thriller. I got in at the ground floot and passed a point of no return regarding reading it in collected form.

1602 (mini)
Alternate super-hero history. Bought because it was written by Neil Gaiman and because the individual issues (rather than the TPB) meant money would go to a cause.

Arrowsmith (mini)
Fantasy/alternate history. This is non-mainstream for comics, so deserves support, and a dream team of Busiek & Pacheco meant I wouldn’t be able to wait.

Astonishing X-Men TPB #1
Straight super-hero. In the words of PVP, Joss Whedon is my master now – Buffy, Angel and Firefly mean he can do anything and I’ll be there. John Cassaday is a stunning artist. But I KNEW this was going to be in trade and didn’t need me buying the comics in order to support it.

Astro City: The Dark Age (ongoing)
Super-hero. This will be collected but Busiek has been away from his pet series for a while, so needed people to know they still cared, and looks to be too interesting a story to wait.

Authority: Revolution (maxi)
Super-hero with a twist. I should have got this in collected form, as it will definitely read better that way, but Brubaker was getting me via Gotham Central and Sleeper, and Nguyen was doing Wildcats, so I couldn’t help myself.

Caper (mini-series)
Judd Winick sets my world on fire with Barry Ween but dampens my ardour with his super-hero work, so this seemed like an interesting compromise. The last arc seemed silly, with some pop culture riffing, but the first two were more powerful and ensured I had no regrets.

Captain America & The Falcon (up to #12)
Super-hero. Priest is the man. He is also the man most likely to have a series he is writing cancelled. So I knew I had to support this. However, either I’m not a big fan of Captain America, the character, or this just didn’t work for me and, although I’m sad another book of his got dumped, I wasn’t as gutted as for Xero or Quantum & Woody or Black Panther or …

Chosen (mini)
Movie treatment. I really wish I hadn’t bought this now. I thought Millar was returning to his Swamp Thing roots, if you’ll pardon the pun, for some mature storytelling. I was wrong.

Daredevil (ongoing)
Street-level super-hero. Possibly the best combo for this book in quite some time; Bendis just has perfect instincts for crime stories and Maleev’s art is beautiful. There have been times when it didn’t quite work, but I’m glad that I have the floppies in my collection, even though I knew they’d be collected.

Desolation Jones (ongoing)
Detective/spy/Ellis. I do have more than a bit of a thing for Ellis’s work – the only work of his I don’t buy straight off is his super-hero stuff – and this seemed (and is) prime Ellis material. There was no way I was waiting for the inevitable trade.

Ex Machina (ongoing)
Political/super-hero. Brian Vaughan has been doing some great things. Harris is an artist I’ve admired since Starman. The idea seemed out of the mainstream enough to worry about the numbers. The work itself has meant that I can’t wait for the next issue.

Fables (ongoing)
Fairy tale with a twist. Started from the beginning, as it looked like it might not make it and now far too hooked to stop. Don’t know if I’ll get the spin-off, though.

Fantastic Four #511–524
Super-hero. Waid & Weiringo are a perfect team for the FF. The series started out at the cheaper price which meant the TPB issue wasn’t considered (although they raised the price later) and it was a (very) minor protest at Marvel having booted them off the first time round. Stopped once Waid & Weiringo finished.

Garth Ennis’s 303 (mini)
Modern war/drama. Ennis is someone whose work I have enjoyed immensely and this seemed to be a return to the sort of material he wanted to be able to do outside of the mainstream. Also, seeing Jacen Burrows in colour was a draw. And doing this at Avatar, even though it will be collected eventually, meant I had to get the floppies.

Gotham Central (ongoing)
Crime (with a hint of super-hero). The numbers on this have never been great, so I’m glad it’s still going. I knew I had to get this because of the idea (being a cop in Gotham), that it was going to be a tough sell, and the creative team. Very glad to be getting the floppies.

Gravity (mini)
Super-hero. Old school super-heroics with a new character was going to need support and this looked too charming to miss.

Hellboy: The Island (mini)
Action/horror. I doubt Mignola needs my money but I only buy Hellboy when he writes and draws, and that has been a while, and seems to be a while in the future until he does it again.

Hunter Killer (ongoing)
Super-hero (with a twist). I thought that the teaming of Waid & Silvestri seemed interesting and there was a different take on the super-powers/government plot. I’m not sure if I’m convinced yet but am still intrigued enough to continue.

Intimates (ongoing)
Super-hero soap opera. With the news that it’s cancelled as of #12, it looks like my buying it to boost the numbers didn’t help. I’ll have to re-read it to see if I’ll keep it in my collection.

Jack Staff (slowly ongoing)
Super-hero, Brit-style. This list of comics covers about a year and a half, and only 4 issues of Jack Staff have come out – how long for the trades? This is very enjoyable stuff from Grist that unfortunately loses momentum due to the large delays between books.

JLA: Another Nail (mini)
Super-hero. This should have been a trade, as it was cheaper, but also because it wasn’t as good as the first, wonderful story. However, Alan Davis is a spectacular artist and I am weak.

JLA: Classified #1–3
Super-hero. Grant Morrison setting up Seven Soldiers, with Ed McGuinness on art. I couldn’t wait. Good decision.

Legion of Super-Heroes (ongoing)
Super-hero (obviously; the clue’s in the title …) I have a soft spot for the LSH. Not a huge fan, mind you, but enough to be sufficiently intrigued by a creative team I like (from Empire and JLA: Year One) to go for the individual comics, as well as the extra pages in the book itself. A bit less angsty-teen stuff and more of the titular aspect would be appreciated.

Losers up to #12 (Wait for trade)
Action/conspiracy. I switched to the trade, perhaps mistakenly, during a cut-back I had over a year ago. I am not a rich man, and can only afford so many comics a week. Some things had to go. Still a big fan, even if I have to wait, but I’m stubborn, so can’t go back to the comics now, especially knowing that it’ll be ending soon.

Ocean (mini)
Sci-fi/action. See Desolation Jones for my Ellis-whoring. Also, Chris Sprouse is in my good books since some LSH stuff, Supreme and Tom Strong.

Outsiders up to issue 12, after which I stopped
Super-hero. Judd Winick doing old school super-hero with Tom Raney on art. Sounded like a good idea at the time. Winick’s dialogue was zingy but his storytelling wasn’t compelling and Raney couldn’t keep a monthly schedule. Don’t miss it.

Planetary (ongoing)
Archaeological super-hero. One of the best books, when it comes out, with a perfect creative team telling a brilliant story.

Powers (ongoing)
Crime/super-hero. Another perfect creative team telling great stories, I’ve been with Powers since the image days and wasn’t going to stop now.

Promethea (maxi)
Magic/super-hero/Alan Moore’s treatise on magic. Although I still have trouble with the last issue (and I don’t want to cut it up), and the story stood still while Moore lectured us on tarot cards and the like, this was an amazing comic. Glad to have the floppies.

The Pulse (ongoing)
Super-hero/news drama (originally). The slowness of publication, the tie-in to the seemingly never-ending Secret Wars, the tie-in to House of M; all have dulled my joy. Needs a turnaround from Bendis to get me enjoying this again.

The Punisher (Max imprint) up to #6, waiting for the trade.
Violence. 'Welcome Back, Frank' was hilarious. Some of the later stuff wasn’t so good, but still enjoyable. This is obviously in collected form and doesn’t need me buying it to keep it going. Strangely, I haven’t bought the trades yet, perhaps based on some negative reviews from fellow bloggers, but I’ll get round to it soon.

PVP v2 (ongoing)
Humour. I have read the online strip for at least four years now and never made a donation to the site. Buying the comic is my way of giving Kurtz some money to keep on doing what he does best.

Queen & Country (sort of ongoing)
Espionage. Wasn’t this Oni’s first monthly comic? I can’t recall but a spy book, about a female spy no less, in black and white from an independent publisher needed support from the start. And I was glad to be there, as this is a great book, which has been knocked off the radar due to Rucka being one of the architects of the Infinite Crisis, which is a shame, but I don’t begrudge him work.

Runaways (ongoing)
Super-hero. I wasn’t sure about this book until I picked up the first issue in a comic shop and read it and I was completely hooked. I’m glad I got the comics because Vaughan does cliff-hangers wonderfully and also because I don’t like digest size for the collection, but mainly because this is one of the most consistently enjoyable books that Marvel is putting out at the moment.

Seaguy (mini)
Morrison-esque. Morrison usually makes me buy the comics anyway, but would have preferred this in the trade as I didn’t enjoy it as much as some of his other work. Personal taste thing, not a quality aspect.

Seven Soldiers (ALL)
Morrison super-hero. These will be collected but I can’t wait that long; all those books with distilled essence of Morrison in them, about super-heroes, in the DC universe, where he can do what he wants? No question.

She-Hulk TPB 1 & 2
Humour/super-hero. I got into this late. This was a great story, with some wonderful art from Bubillo and a lightness of touch from Slott that means I'll be buying the second season in the monthly format.

Sleeper Season 2
Conspiracy/thriller/slight super-hero. This had trouble with low sales from the first ‘season’ which I also got in comic form because I knew it would be a tough sell. Glad to have got these, as it was a cracking story.

Smax (mini)
Fantasy. Alan Moore is a god of comics. Top Ten was genius. No contest.

Strangehaven (ongoing, sort of)
Categorizable? I was in on the ground floor anyway, before the schedule went from sort of monthly to annual, so I’ll be with this in comic format for the duration.

Stupid Comics #3
Humour. I guess these are almost collections in their own right, so I don’t know if they’ll be collected again. However, I don’t know if I’ll be getting this again, so the point is moot.

Superman: Birthright (maxi)
Super-hero. I don’t read Superman, so this seemed like a way to check out the granddaddy of super-heroes, with Waid displaying his Supes love and the gorgeous artwork of Yu to entrance. I should have probably waited for the trade but I’m happy this has a place among my comic books.

Supreme Power (ongoing)
Super-hero with a twist. The team that brought us Midnight Nation on a ‘mature’ take on an alternate JLA had me salivating. I’m not sure about the hiatus, downgrade to Marvel Knights or the spin-offs (Jurgens on art rather than Frank?) but I’ll keep buying this instalments, whenever they turn up.

Ultimate Fantastic Four up to #6 then wait for trade
Super-hero. I thought this would be an interesting take on the FF which, when done right, can be an excellent venue for 'mad, crazy ideas'. The first arc didn’t really do anything for me, so I went for the ‘wait for trade’ policy that is scaring the PTB in the big publishing companies. I subsequently bought the Ellis-written stories in this form and thoroughly enjoyed them, made more enjoyable by being able to read in one sitting.

Ultimate X-Men up to #45
Super-hero. Bendis & Finch make for a good team, enough to make me weaken and get their storyline in instalments. I haven’t got round to getting Vaughan’s stories in collected form yet.

Ultimates 2 (ongoing)
Super-hero. Millar may have problems as a writer but Ultimates seems just perfect for right now. I was never a big Avengers fan, so the stories are new to me, and the Hitch art is simply magnificent. I could probably wait for the collection but enjoying it too much to switch.

Usagi Yojimbo (ongoing)
Anthropomorphic/samurai/history. Simply brilliant comics. If I could afford it, I would buy the trades as well, just to be able to have a shelf of Usagi books on display. Sakai is a modern master of comic book storytelling and the Usagi Yojimbo box I have is a proud part of my collection.

Vimanarama (mini)
Bollywood/fantasy/Morrison-esque. I debated this one for a while but succumbed in the end. A fun, if not earth-shattering tale (well, I mean, in the book the earth might have shattered but … you know what I mean), it was nice seeing Bond on art duties again. Could have waited for the trade.

Wanted (mini)
Super-hero with a twist. Apart from the last page, this was quite good, if a tad juvenile in places. Lovely art from Jones and Millar doing an intriguing if slight tale. Could have waited for the trade.

Warren Ellis’s Apparat comics
Pulp variations. Until the recent Bad Signal said otherwise, these weren’t going to be collected; there was supposed to be no choice that these were going to be individual comics only. Still, I enjoyed three out of four immensely, so no regrets.

We3 (mini)
Let’s call it sci-fi action. I didn’t get this based on my reaction to Seaguy. Then the internet went crazy for it, so I thought I’d get the trade. Then the trade was more expensive than the individual comics, so I felt annoyed. Luckily, Gosh! Comics, my LCS, had the three issues as a set for £5, less than the individual comics, so I got lucky. Oh, yes, it was brilliant as well.

Wildcats v3 to the end
Super-hero with a twist. This was a wonderful take on the super-hero team and was always going to be a hard sell, so I felt obliged to get the comic as it came out, a decision I don’t regret, as this was immensely satisfying and a shame to see it cancelled due to low numbers.

Wonder Woman up to #217
Super-hero. I decided to give this a try solely due to Rucka’s writing. The early issues, where fans were complaining of nothing happening, were perhaps the most interesting, exploring Diana’s mission and place in the DCU. The later stuff defining a nemesis for Diana were less interesting and I bolted when I heard of the involvement with Infinite Crisis. DC’s attitude to collecting books meant this seemed an unlikely choice for the format, so I don’t mind that I got the comics. However, I’m going to need another read-through of the books I have to decide whether they stay or not.

So, apart from displaying the narrow range of my tastes and my unhealthy taste for super-heroes (albeit with a twist), what have we learned?

Well, if a book isn’t working for me, I should give it fewer issues to impress me. It may be harsh, but a book has to grab me, and how, otherwise it’s not doing its job. The cutting down on weekly comics allows for more experimentation, although my range (I feel) is limited by my tastes. For example, a book that I stopped prior to the timeframe in this experiment was Human Target – Peter Milligan is a great writer but I wasn’t actively looking forward to this book when it came out, even though I could tell it was a good book. Another worry is trying things based on writers; this doesn’t always work. Judd Winick is an example; I’ve tried The Outsiders, his Green Arrow and a few others, none of which match his non-super-hero work.

So, if there’s anyone still left reading who has detected some glimmer of my tastes and has an idea of the sort of thing I would like, but am not currently availing myself of, please let me know. I’m willing to try new things (he said, sounding like a pervy swinger) so feel free to leave suggestions in my comments section.

Monday, 8 August 2005

Write here, write now

This is going to be a bit nomadic and aimless, with some thoughts and things I want to remember. On with the show and don’t munch on your popcorn too loudly; please be considerate to other patrons.

Anyone else getting lots of Russian spam? I get an inbox full of subject headings containing Cyrillic letters, which is rather cool. A new source of revenue for the Russian mafia?

Over at the Pulse, Ellis talks about NextWave. Now, I’ll admit that I’m Ellis’s man-whore he-bitch, but this does sound kind of interesting. Immonen’s art has an animated series quality to it that is very pleasing to the eye and Warren seems to be going in to this project with his tongue so far in his cheek he’s going to require extensive oral surgery to remove it, so it could be something to watch.

In other comics news, Wizard World Chicago happened this weekend; see this link for a handy index to all the news, where some people go exclusive for other people, yet more comics are announced, and stuff happened, mostly to the reaction of 'Meh'. I'll look forward to Brubaker and Lark on Daredevil, but I might wait for the trade, despite knowing in advance that I will enjoy it. However, via Jog, the bit of bad news out of WWC is that The Intimates is cancelled as of #12 (you have to read to near the end of the article for the one line that mentions it, so I don't feel too stupid for missing it on my first read through). I feel bad now for my comments about The Intimates in my last post. More grist for the mill concerning why I pick up certain comics.

Which brings me to some of my rambly shit. Jog writes (and writes and writes – the individual posts tend towards the long) good posts; they are intelligent and make me feel inadequate and make me wonder why I do this blogging thing.

Now, I’ll try not to get all whiny, so bear with me. There are some excellent comic blogs around that provide different coverage of the wide world of comics: Mike’s experience of working in a comic shop (and his encyclopedic knowledge of comics); Dave’s Long Box for humour; the sharp writing style of Johnny Bacardi; the cynical and witty approach of another comic shop worker at postmodernbarney, to name a few off the top of my head.

So why do I write this blog?

I don’t have an encyclopedic knowledge of the form, I don’t experiment in the more artistic avenues that the medium embraces, and I don’t have the critical powers of some (despite the title of my blog).

I think the main reason, apart from the enjoyment of writing, was to talk about comics (and film and television and whatever) in a forum where like-minded individuals could possibly engage in discussion, as I am particularly shy when it comes to even commenting on people’s posts in Haloscan, which is pretty pathetic, I know.

This is complicated by the Delay Factor – the majority of the comic bloggers are American and get their comics (and film and television) earlier than us Brits, so I miss out on some discussion due to the fast pace of the web and the nature of blogs themselves. When I lived and worked in the US, I felt delighted to be on even footing when it came to comics and films and (some) television programmes – when I returned to the US, I had to take myself off my film buff mailing list because it was depressing seeing them talk about films I wouldn’t be seeing for some time.

Anyway, I was going to ask why other people blog, but I don’t think there are sufficient readers to initiate a discussion (which isn’t a desperate plea for comments, rather an honest assessment of a blog which lost a lot of momentum when it went on hiatus for several months) and is a feeble excuse for not discussing it further myself. I just wanted to see if the act of writing about the concept behind it would crystallize my thoughts. I’m not sure it worked but it was enjoyable doing it nonetheless. For me, it’s not about getting my blog on the links section of other bloggers (although I am happy and proud when I do see it – I’d be talking shit if I didn’t) or getting lots of hits on the site meter, although it’s nice to know that people are reading this blog. I want to write because I love comics and film and television and comedy and want to see those thoughts published and hopefully get better about writing about them. We’ll take it from there after that.

That’s the rambly shit finished, btw. I have some ideas for specific topics that I will blog about, so look forward to genuine, possibly original, content in the next few days.

Sunday, 7 August 2005

Another Comics Round-up

More comic reviews? What is this – some sort of comics blog?

In my preferred reading order:

PVP #0
I really enjoy PVP – the artwork, the humour and the pop culture referencing all appeal to me in a variety of ways. This PVP sampler is a strange collection of different strips from the vast archives, giving a flavour of what to expect if you go to the site or pick up the comic book. The story at the end, explaining why a troll exists in the world of a computer magazine, is the reason I picked up the book – like the previous Dork Storm published PVP, it was the new material in the non-strip format that gives Scott a chance to stretch his wings and tell a complete story. Reason enough to pick what is essentially an advert for the PVP comic book.

Stupid Comics #3
I think I first dug the artistic styling of Jim Mahfood in the first Clerks comics. There's a funky cartoonish quality to the linework that I enjoyed, so I looked out for his other work. Hence picking up Stupid Comics, a collection of his work for magazines. The first two were amusing, if not astounding. This latest collection is very uneven. His targets are admirable, if repetitive and a little obvious, which might work in monthly magazines, but appear devoid of creativity read together. Some of the strips seemed like they've been knocked out in a few moments, which seems a bit insulting to his audience. Maybe I just like the way he draws himself because it reminds me of the way I look, but I don't know if it will be enough to bring me back for more.

Gotham Central #34
Now, this is the real deal. This is good comics. Batman defending himself against a cop, taking her gun, the Teen Titans showing up to confirm it's not Robin, Robin himself telling the same to Stacy on the roof, even the humour of Starfire turning up at the precinct and the effect she has on people, including Maggie Sawyer and Renee, this is a great example of why I buy comics. Kano seems to be coming into his own, not trying to ape Lark anymore, making this a complete package. Comic of the week for me.

The Intimates #10
Joe Casey's Wildcats was a brilliant take on the modern super-hero team, which was why I thought I would get The Intimates, as well as feeling that I was helping out a title that was probably going to get low sales (I think it's a British empathy for the underdog or something, I'm not sure.) Now, after 10 issues, I think I can say that it is a good book (although not on top form for the 'summer vacation' storyline in my opinion) that is done well, although I prefer Camuncoli to Iwahashi and D'Amda, but is not for me. I'm not sure if this a great explanation but it's something I've been thinking about (and will probably blog about shortly) regarding whether a piece of art is good or not and whether I enjoy or it or not, irrespective of its quality, and I think that The Intimates, while possessing good moments and ideas, does not speak to me as a reader, which is either a deficiency on my part or something else entirely.

I'm beginning to waffle (which is the point a blog, I know, but still ...), which is a good sign to stop. More next time.

Friday, 5 August 2005

Clutch of Comics Culture

Wherein I prattle on about comic-related things.

Winging their way to my grubby mitts via my excellent LCS:

Gotham Central #34
Intimates #10
PVP #0
Stupid Comics #3

Gotham Central (soon to be Streets of Gotham, according to Rich Johnston – will Rucka still be on board? – who also has photos of where I shop, Gosh Comics, if you were interested) is nearly always excellent, and the current storyline about a dead Robin is superb. Intimates is a book which I’m not sure I’m getting top value enjoyment out of, so I’m not sure how much longer it will stay on my list – please tell me otherwise if you have a view on the subject. I have much love for the antics of PVP so, even though this is an unnecessary introduction for me to the funny of Scott Kurtz, I can’t help myself. Stupid Comics sees Jim Mahfood doing his Evan Dorkin stuff; he’s not as good as the Dork master himself, but he has a nice style and can be very funny on occasion.

I’ve been away, so missed some stuff. Such as:

The leaking of Warren Ellis’s new Marvel team book go here for Warren talking about it and then here for Stuart Immonen talking about it, because I am an Ellis whore and will probably buy this, even if it does sound silly.

Here you can read Brian Vaughan talking intelligently about the film option on Ex Machina.

Mike Sterling made me laugh with what is presumably an old joke but one I had never heard before in his post titled The Comics FAQ:

WHAT DOES THE "X" IN "X-MEN" STAND FOR?

-- It's the Roman numeral representation of approximately how many X-Men
related titles are on the stands at any given time.

Joss Whedon talks about everything, including comics and why Warren Ellis is a God to him (found via Ellis himself – these creative types are so cliquey, aren't they?).

The MillarWorld Magazine has Garth Ennis revealing the origin of Section Eight, heh, heh, bueno …

And of course, there was the Wizard/Heroes Con fiasco – for more lucid and intelligent response, see this article by the estimable Paul O’Brien or, for an artistic interpretation, Scott Kurtz.

Time for me to read some comics. Enjoy your weekend, folks.

Thursday, 4 August 2005

Bringing the comics criticism

Without further ado, some Reviews:

Runaways v2 #6
Vaughan brings home 'True Believers' with resolution, secrets revealed and mysteries begun. It was obvious that Victor is going to come around, the enjoyment should be in the how. The 'moment' isn't anything extraordinary, as I've come to expect from BKV, but is dialogue and characters more than make up for it. I got a kick out of seeing Rick Jones again, after Peter David made him such a great character (and Vaughan mentions the autobiography here, which is a nice touch.) Nico is turning into a smart leader, which is good. And could that be a dead member of the Runaways at the end...? Good stuff, ably matched by Alphona on art.

Legion of Super-Heroes (volume who knows) #8
I sorely missed Kitson's art this month - I know some find his work a little stiff, but I've always enjoyed it since I first saw it in a 2000AD story called "The Fists of Stan Lee" and LSH wasn't quite the same. Sharpe isn't bad, just not as consistent, especially on the faces, and the torsos seemed overly muscular. The story sees the in-fighting between Brainy and Cos come to a head, with Waid bringing through the teenager aspect of the characters. It was nice to see the team use its powers, even if it was on each other. However, even with the extra pages, Waid is taking a long time to get things going, which is unusual for him.

Astro City: The Dark Age Book One #2 (Winner of Long Winded Title Award)
This issue seemed more like the Astro City of old; after setting the tone in the first issue, Busiek gets things in gear with the reaction to the Silver Agent's trial and the rest of the super-powered inhabitants getting cameos, as well as the reaction to these events from the perspective of Royal and Charles, and their history with the Agent. Anderson tells the story well, but his art seems on the messy side of 'loose' for my tastes. Compare his rendition of the Blue Knight on the rooftop with the cover, for example, or the face of the newsreader on page two. Maybe it's just me. Still, good to have Astro City back.

The Pulse #10
This was my first taste of House of M - the glimpse I got seems like it is an okay alternate universe story and that Bendis has got the world mapped out. Based on this, I might be tempted to get the trade. Strangely, it all seems to be about Bendis's love of Clint Barton, which is fair enough, if you like that sort of thing. This issue sees the world of news and how it is affected by the House of M, and Clint Barton explaining to Kat Farrell what the world should be like, and a glimpse of the stubborness of the character. Lark and Gaudiano make for a strange art team; glimpses of the two talents without the quality of either shining through. I think Pulse might have to put on the Wait For Trade list from now on, though.

Hellboy: The Island #2
In which we learn the origin of Hellboy's right hand and the wheels are set in motion for the future of the Hellboy universe. Mignola's art is a beautifully moody as ever and the strange sadness of our hero comes out with the few words he actually speaks. Your continued enjoyment will depend on how much you love Lovecraftian monsters, which may mean I pass on future stories. Also, Mignola seems to be setting up the stories but getting others to finish them off, which takes away a large part of the charm and reason for reading, namely his wonderful pencils. Whatever happened to one chap telling their own story?